Collision Insurance: A Complete Guide to Coverage, Costs, and Common Questions

If you own a car, understanding collision insurance is crucial—it protects your vehicle from accident-related damage, but many drivers are unsure what it covers, when to drop it, and how it differs from comprehensive insurance.

In this guide, we’ll answer the top-searched collision insurance questions, including:

✅ What collision insurance covers (and doesn’t)
✅ How it differs from comprehensive insurance
✅ When you should (and shouldn’t) keep it
✅ Average payouts for common collisions
✅ Key factors that lead to accidents

What Is Collision Insurance?

Collision insurance is auto coverage that pays for damage to your car after an accident, regardless of fault. It covers:

Crashes with another vehicle (e.g., rear-end collisions)
Single-car accidents (e.g., hitting a pole or guardrail)
Rollovers

🚗 What it does NOT cover:

Theft, vandalism, or weather damage (requires comprehensive insurance)
Medical bills or other drivers’ repairs (requires liability insurance)

📌 Source: Insurance Information Institute (III)

What Does Collision Insurance Cover?

1. Common Covered Scenarios

Rear-end collisions (Average payout: $3, 000-$ 7,000)
Side-impact crashes (T-bones)
Hit-and-run accidents (if uninsured motorist coverage is absent)
Pothole or road debris damage

2. What’s Not Covered?

Mechanical failures (engine/transmission issues)
Normal wear and tear
Intentional damage

📌 Source: Forbes – Collision Insurance Guide

Collision vs. Comprehensive Insurance: Key Differences

Feature	Collision Insurance	Comprehensive Insurance
Covers	Accidents with objects/vehicles	Non-crash incidents (theft, fire, hail)
Required?	No, unless leasing/financing	No, but lenders often require both
Best For	Drivers in high-traffic areas	Areas prone to theft/natural disasters

🔹 Do you need both? Yes, if you want full coverage (especially for new cars).

📌 Source: NerdWallet – Comprehensive vs. Collision

Do You Need Collision Insurance?

✅ Keep It If:

You lease or finance your car (lenders usually require it).
You drive in high-traffic areas (more accident risk).
Your car is new or expensive to repair.

❌ Drop It If:

Your car is old or low-value (check Kelley Blue Book).
You can afford repairs out-of-pocket.
You rarely drive (low accident risk).

📌 Rule of Thumb: If annual premium > 10% of car’s value, consider dropping it.

📌 Source: Consumer Reports – When to Drop Collision

Final Verdict: Is Collision Insurance Worth It?

New/expensive car? Yes.
Old/paid-off car? Maybe not.
High-risk area? Strong yes.

🔗 Compare Quotes: The Zebra | Policygenius